How to Have Difficult Conversations
The elephant in the room, the hard chat, the “I will deal with that later”.
Having that difficult conversation can be the one thing many of us dread at work.
A survey of 2,000 workers found, 57% of respondents said they would do almost anything to avoid a tough conversation; and 52% said that they would instead put up with a negative situation at work than having to talk about it (Chartered Management Institute, July 2015).
Throughout my career, I have had to have difficult conversations. During a performance appraisal, inappropriate and harmful behaviour and even redundancies. These discussions have the potential to become emotional and unpredictable and may managers and employees feeling vulnerable and open to criticism.
Due to this, many people avoid difficult conversation and giving honest feedback. Which can mean the situation continues to worsen. Moreover, as a leader, it is often expected that you know how to have these confronting conversations.
So what if you have never done this before?
Where do you begin, and how do you make sure it is a respectful and timely conversation?
Here are my top six tips for getting through difficult conversations, keeping your relationships intact and achieving positive outcomes from them.
1. Save the Surprises for the Birthday Party
As Benjamin Franklin famously said, “honesty is the best policy”.
Let the person in question know from the outset the purpose of the meeting. Don’t invite them for “a coffee and a chat”, leaving them blindsided at the start of the conversation.
In my corporate life, I was once asked by my manager to have a coffee catch up. I turned up, and my manager and HR also turned up and went on to explain that due to a restructure my role would be changing, and my team size and accountabilities were increasing.
A more appropriate approach is to explain the meeting purpose upfront, give me time to prepare myself mentally and then have a far more constructive discussion around the change in the situation.
2. Your Place or Mine?
Depending on what you need to communicate, you want to ensure the environment and timings are right. For example, sitting in your office, behind your desk, or in the open-plan kitchen, may not be conducive to open and honest rapport.
Conversely, taking someone to public, noisy café to “have the conversation away from work” probably won’t work. Plus the free cappuccino may not make up for the critical feedback.
Instead, book a private meeting room in advance. Also book the meeting room for longer than required, so that the person receiving the news has time to digest things in private. If you think the meeting may become emotional, bring tissues and water. The aim is to improve employee engagement and performance not decimate it.
3. Timing is Everything
Timing is critical. If you notice something is not going well provide feedback in real-time.
For example, “I saw you missed the last two deadlines. Let’s get together tomorrow and work through this. ” This will be far more effective than sharing this thought nine months later at the end of year performance review. By acting quickly, you are giving your team member the best chance at correcting performance and getting back on track.
Also, have the conversation as soon as possible. Don’t schedule the meeting for later in the week and let people stress about the conversation. Ideally, have these conversations first thing in the morning and then if required, give your team member time to reflect and digest the discussion.
Your role as a leader is to leverage timely feedback to drive improved performance, not punish people.
4. Do Not Assume
Before you meet with your team member, establish exactly why the meeting is occurring and what you expect the meeting outcome to be. Depending on the complexity of the conversation, discuss the approach with your manager and an HR rep. Do your research beforehand and ensure your facts are correct. Don’t assume anything and never let yours (or other’s) opinions cloud the situation.
By not assuming, this will enable you to answer your team members questions rather than “I will get back to you on that one” or “we need to continue this at a later date”. These are not an ideal response if your team member is upset or anxious. If it is a fact-finding meeting, be impartial and open to all manner of information your staff member gives you.
5. Skip the Small Talk
Save the small talk for your backyard BBQ and don’t evade a difficult conversation by spending the first 10 minutes making small talk. Lay it bare and remain sensitive and compassionate, acknowledging that they are probably feeling anxious.
Once you have provided context on the issue, it is essential not to rush your team member’s response or their understanding. Give them time to digest the matter. Remember you have had more time to deliberate on this issue and now it is their turn. Let them ask questions and work through their concerns.
Try and make it as constructive an exchange as possible. You want to preserve the relationship.
6. Stay Calm
Give yourself a check-up from the neck up.
Make sure you go into the conversation with a clear mindset and with your emotions in check. Some meetings may become emotional, which can be challenging. Acknowledge emotions such as sarcasm, defensiveness, anger.
Allow your team member to work through this, however, never respond in the same way. Always allow them their dignity and due respect, but keep the meeting on track.
7. Follow Through
Don’t have the meeting and then pretend it never happened.
If there needs to be a follow-up conversation, make sure it occurs. If you need to check in on your team members welfare, make sure you do. If they need to provide anything to you, make sure they do so. It is about achieving the predetermined outcomes and rectifying the issue that existed.
Never intentionally avoid that person. A friend once worked for a CEO who had to make several senior staff redundant. Once it happened, they then avoided them for the remaining four weeks they were in the company. They felt humiliated, isolated, and took it very personally.
These are just a few insights into how to manage difficult conversations and to achieve positive outcomes from them.
About the Author
Rajiv is the author of the upcoming book, How To Grow Tall Poppies - A Practical Guide to Developing High-Performance Teams. Subscribe here to stay on top of the latest leadership trends and my upcoming book.
Rajiv is passionate about improving the business world—one leader at a time. With experience leading teams in senior roles across the banking, energy and technology sectors, and interviewing over 500 high-performance teams and leaders, Rajiv knows what it takes to create a high-performance team environment.
Rajiv combines real-world experience with evidenced-based coaching approaches as an International Coaching Federation certified coach to support leaders to maximise the potential of their teams through his company, Bare Coaching. He has worked with, guided and developed leaders in universities, technology firms, wine companies, start-ups and small businesses.